1. "A Boat beneath a Sunny Sky" by Lewis Carroll
2. "Coda" by Basil Bunting
3. "I heard a Fly buzz- when I died" by Emily Dickinson
4. "Under the Vulture-tree" by David Bottoms
"The Arrow and the Song" by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Part 2: What I Think
I liked "The Arrow and the Song" and "Under the Vulture-tree" the best because I could connect to them the most. I really like archery and I am an ambitious birder. When I have to recite a poem, if I don't like them, I can't motivate myself to remember it. Formerly, I had memorized "Mushrooms" and another poem about owls. Because I like these poems, I never had to kick myself to learn them. Rather on the contrary, I enjoyed reading and rereading them in order to memorize them. "The Arrow and the Song" and "Under the Vulture-tree" are the most interesting to me so it will be not difficult to motivate myself to memorize them.
I did not like the other three as much. Either they just weren't interesting to me personally or couldn't connect with them. "A Boat beneath a Sunny Sky" is about remembering a beautiful world that you are no longer a part of. Fortunately, I have never had that experience and can therefore not connect with the meaning of the poem.
Of the two I like the best, I will pick "Under the Vulture-tree" because "The Arrow and the Song" is much shorter and I am not so confident in my poem reciting abilities to score top points with a very simple and short poem. They both are excellent poems that I like very much but I will peruse and further analyze "Under the Vulture-tree".
I knew when I read the poem that I could connect with it. Since I was very young I have been a supporter of misjudged animals. My sixth birthday party was spider themed; I have never had a princess party. When I was three my ideal future career was that of a shark scientist. I disliked ponies and dolphines because they were the "good" and "nice" animals. I loved bugs too. "Creepy crawlies" were my garden friends. But when I read this poem for the first time I thought of fifth grade. Another fifth grade teacher had a non-bullying poster. It was a vulture with a huge red "X" across it. When I asked her what this meant she said it was because vultures pick on animals. They do pick on animals, but literaly, not symbolically like she was portraying it. The eat dead animals. Dead animals. Animals left uneaten by vultures would attract other animals to it. The majestic bald eagle, our national bird is a carrion eater. They would rather scavenge for rotting flesh than fish for their food, yet no one thinks of them as bullys. Vultures do the enviroment a favor, actually. Some animals, left uneaten will start to bring desease. Magotts and flies fester on decaying flesh. This is dangerous for animals that eat the carrion later. Another reason vultures are disliked in society is their unapealing apreance. Ugly, vicious, disgusting birds, right? Nope. Their bald heads and long necks help keep the bird clean as it eats the meat inside. Also they are known to fly long distences after every meal to find water to cleanse themselves. They are surprisingly clean creatures. And vicious? They don't kill animals- ever. They weren't made for it. As you can probably tell I have alot to say in vulture's defense. The same can be said about spiders, sharks, owls, and other very misunderdstood and misjudged animals. The last line of the poem, "...with mercy enough to consume us all and give us wings" shows how the vultures do help the enviroment. My favorite nickname for them has always been "nature's recyclers". Because that's what they do; return the dead's nutrients to the earth.
Part 3: Scoring Criteria
Conveying the meaning of the poem to the audiance will be easy, since I have such a strong opinion about it. Also, my physical articulation is pretty decent and my voice is clear and easily heard. I don't whimper. So I don't think I will have to work very hard to make sure I meaningfully portray the poem's themes and articulate them well.
I can prepare well for recitations, but calming myself before a preformance may pose a challenge. I get nervous and speed up, which can lead to mispronounciations. The worst thing about getting nervous for me is saying something, then immediately forgetting what you just said and having no idea what to say next. This is particularly frustrating during presentations and preformances. The second criteria that will be hard is the dramatic appropriatness. I am not very good at making sure I use my hands to enhance what I am saying. But by being nervous that I am not acomplished at this, I may overuse dramatic appeances and make the poem seem insincere.
Part 4: Videos
Jackson Hille recites "Forgetfulness" in a very entertaining way. This makes the preformance successfull in the way that it is never boring or make you wonder what in the world he is talking about. Plus, it's a topic we can all relate to; we all forget things. This makes the poem easy to understand in a very interesting way to the audience.
Madison Nieemeyer recites "I Am Waiting". This is a repetive, long poem that could become quickely boring. The way she tells it, however, is not boring though it is repetive and lengthy. Her vocal nuances and enunciations are perfect for the slight urgency of the poem. Also the way she uses her body language enhances the meaning without taking away from the poem or is distracting.
Part 5: Summary
I think this competition will be a great challenge. I love to read and recite poetry, but it is done so unnaturally that it makes you work hard. I have my heart set on winning, but I realize my competition will be feirce. Reciting poetry like the people in the videos do really exposes you; it would be so much easier to just say a memorized poem instead to reciting it in a meaningful way. But it's a risk I am going to take to get to the school competition.
No comments:
Post a Comment